LEGITIMACY AND LEGALITY OF REVOLUTION IN THE THEORETICAL THOUGHT OF EDMUND BURKE

Predrag Terzić

doi:10.5937/ptp2601137T

Authors

Predrag Terzić Institute for Political Studies, Belgrade https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3896-6217

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5937/ptp2601137T

Keywords:

legitimacy, legality, revolution, state authority, Edmund Burke, Slobodan Jovanović

Abstract

Within legal doctrine, a longstanding debate has persisted as to whether revolution may be regarded as a legitimate and lawful means of altering state authority. From the perspective of a democratic constitutional order, revolution constitutes a violent change of state authority; however, within certain ideological frameworks, it is perceived as an instrument for transforming authoritarian regimes. Historical experience demonstrates that while some revolutions have constituted the only “effective” remedy against autocracy, others have served merely as a means of its establishment. The French Bourgeois Revolution and the October Socialist Revolution represent the opposing poles of these interpretations. Each, in its own manner, revealed both positive and negative consequences, as they were ultimately betrayed by their leaders, who appropriated them for their own ends. This study employs a range of scientific methods—most prominently historical, comparative, inductive, and hypothetico-deductive—in pursuit of an integral approach aimed at highlighting the importance of Edmund Burke’s theoretical thought. It should not be overlooked that the distinguished Serbian legal theorist Slobodan Jovanović devoted particular attention to this author, especially in the context of examining revolution as a means of violently replacing one political order with another.

References

Burke, E. (2001). Razmišljanja o revoluciji u Francuskoj [Reflections on the Revolution in France]. Beograd: Filip Višnjić

Jovanović, S. (1935). Iz istorije političkih doktrina, knj. 1 [From the History of Political Doctrines, Vol. 1]. Beograd: Izdavačko i knjižarsko preduzeće Geca Kon

Jones, E. (2015). Conservatism, Edmund Burke, and the Invention of a Political Tradition, c. 1885–1914. The Historical Journal, 58(4), pp. 1115–1139

Young, E. (1994). Rediscovering Conservatism: Burkean Political Theory and Constitutional Interpretation. North Carolina Law Review, 3(72), pp. 619–724

Lukić, R. (1989). Francuska revolucija i revolucionarni proces [The French Revolution and the Revolutionary Process]. Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu, 37(6), pp. 653–659

Milosavljević, B. (2011). Politika i moral u teoriji države Slobodana Jovanovića [Politics and Morality in the Theory of State by Slobodan Jovanović]. Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu, 59(1), pp. 273–293

Milosavljević, B. (2012). Kulturni obrazac i pojam polu intelektualca [The concepts of the cultural model and the semi-intellectual]. Kultura, (137), pp. 127–143. DOI: 10.5937/kultura1237127M

Milošević Stolić, J. & Marček, J. (2017). Menadžerske kompetencije oficirskog kadra Vojske Srbije [Managerial Competences of the Officer Cadre of the Serbian Armed Forces]. Vojno delo, 69(2), pp. 194–218

Raunić, R. (2013). Edmund Burke. In: Kulenović, E. (ed.), Moderna politička teorija [Modern Political Theory] (pp. 155–202). Zagreb: Fakultet političkih znanosti Sveučilišta

Starčević, S. & Kajtez, I. (2018). Berkov doprinos proučavanju vojske kao društvene institucije [Burke’s Contribution to the Study of the Military as a Social Institution]. Teme, 42(3), pp. 779–797

Stanovčić, V. (2022). Političke ideje i ideologije [Political Ideas and Ideologies]. Beograd: Centar za demokratiju Fakulteta političkih nauka

Terzić, P. (2020). Ideja slobode u pravno-političkim delima Slobodana Jovanovića [The Idea of Freedom in the Legal and Political Works of Slobodan Jovanović]. Srpska politička misao, 68(2), pp. 79–98

Terzić, P. & Joksić, I. (2021). Francuska buržoaska revolucija iz pera Slobodana Jovanovića [The French Bourgeois Revolution through the Writings of Slobodan Jovanović]. Politička revija, 68(2), pp. 311–325

Trajković, M. (2011). Pravo i moral u svetlu prihvatanja i prinude [Law and Morality in the Light of Consent and Coercion]. Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta, Novi Sad 45(1), pp. 257–269

Trotsky, L. (1973). Izdana revolucija I. [The Revolution Betrayed I]. Rijeka: Otokar Keršovani